Arbitral Award

On May 24, 2022, an international arbitration tribunal constituted under the Arbitration Rules of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (“Arbitral Tribunal”) issued its final award confirming that Ecuador’s actions violated the Service Agreement for the Exploration and/or Exploitation of Hydrocarbons in the Singue Block of the Ecuadorian Amazon Region signed with Gente Oil (the “Agreement”). The Arbitral Tribunal ordered Ecuador to pay Gente Oil damages for material and moral losses, plus interest and a portion of Gente Oil’s legal costs and attorneys’ fees.

The Final Award is available below.

Key points of the final award

  • The Arbitration Tribunal confirmed the legality of the Contract.
  • Ecuador recognizes that the Contract is highly beneficial to Ecuador and therefore opposes its termination.
  • Ecuador breached the Contract. [paragraphs 1451 (e) and (g)]
  • Ecuador “failed to perform [the Contract] in good faith and caused moral damages” to Gente Oil. [para. 1187]
  • The grounds for the Comptroller's Recommendation in General Report DASE-045-2017 to reduce the Tariff are “erroneously analyzed and [are] contrary to the economic balance of the Contract.” [para. 1017]
  • The private prosecution presented by the Attorney General's Office on behalf of the Ecuadorian State in the criminal proceedings includes "allegations contrary to what the Secretariat, before 2018, and likewise the Sectoral Ministry, had unequivocally stated." [para. 1277]
  • In the criminal proceedings, the Attorney General's Office "distorted the terms of the Contract and the calculation of the alleged damages suffered by the [Ecuadorian] State." [para. 1187]
  • Ecuador's behavior "must be considered malicious." [para. 1277]
  • The Arbitral Tribunal ordered Ecuador to pay compensation of more than $10 million for its breaches of contract. [para. 1452 (a), (b) and (c)]
  • Additionally, the Arbitral Tribunal ordered Ecuador to pay moral damages to repair damage to the reputation and good name of Gente Oil. [paras. 1278-1281 and 1452 (d)]

Judgment in action for annulment of the award

As a result of the Final Award, the Republic of Ecuador filed an appeal for annulment with the Court of Appeals in Santiago, Chile, the seat of the arbitration. Among other arguments, the Republic of Ecuador alleged that the Final Award violated public policy. In its judgment of October 18, 2024, the Court rejected the appeal in its entirety and upheld the validity of the Final Award.

Key points of the annulment ruling

  • The Court found that the Final Award did not violate public policy in the sense that it did not violate the principles of legality and good faith and the duty to provide reasons (page 33).
  • Regarding the judgment against the Republic of Ecuador for contractual moral damages as stated in the Final Award, the Tribunal confirmed its adherence to public policy. Specifically, the Tribunal found that the Arbitral Award was consistent with public policy because, “after assessing the evidence, it [considered] that the defendant’s conduct must be considered intentional, at least in the form of dolus eventualis (reckless disregard for the law).” The Tribunal also considered that the arbitral tribunal had “prudently” assessed the amount of compensation, and therefore noted that “the arbitral tribunal did provide reasons in its award for the admissibility and assessment of the moral damages it awarded; hence, the defect alleged in the appeal is not apparent” (page 33). 
  • With regard to the principle of legality, the Court found that “no violation of the principle of legality, as understood in our domestic law, is apparent. Indeed, in the terms already stated, the award condemned the Republic of Ecuador for the actions that it deemed to be attributable to it” (page 33).
  • With regard to the principle of good faith, the Court found that it was not subject to review by means of an appeal for annulment, as this would mean a review of the substance of the award.
  • Regarding the duty to provide reasons, the Court noted that “the award contains an extensive assessment of the evidence and considerations regarding the reasons why the court partially accepts the claim and orders the Republic of Ecuador to provide some of the requested benefits” (page 33).

As a result, the Final Award is mandatory and binding. Furthermore, there is no other recourse under local or international law, and it must therefore be understood as a final decision.